Difference between revisions of "M Is for Magic"
(→Review) |
|||
Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
}} | }} | ||
− | '''''M Is for Magic''''' is compilation of short stories written by [[Neil Gaiman]], published on 2007-06-06. Despite the book's theme implying it's for children, most of the subject matter is more appropriate for adults | + | '''''M Is for Magic''''' is compilation of short stories written by [[Neil Gaiman]], published on 2007-06-06. Despite the book's theme implying it's for children, most of the subject matter is more appropriate for teens and adults. The Spanish title is much more accurate which translates to, "the cemetery without tombstones and other black stories." Nearly all of the stories in the book were previously published in Gaimen's other anthologies. |
==Personal== | ==Personal== | ||
{{BookStatus | {{BookStatus | ||
| Own = | | Own = | ||
− | | Read = | + | | Read = Audiobook read by [[Neil Gaiman]]. |
− | | Finished = | + | | Finished = 2024-04-16. |
}} | }} | ||
Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
| "Troll Bridge" || A tale about a little boy who meets a hungry bridge troll that will spare his life if he promises to return to be eaten when he's older. | | "Troll Bridge" || A tale about a little boy who meets a hungry bridge troll that will spare his life if he promises to return to be eaten when he's older. | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | | "Don't Ask Jack" || A cursed jack-in-the-box drives a family mad. Mildly creepy, but too short | + | | "Don't Ask Jack" || A cursed jack-in-the-box drives a family mad. Mildly creepy, but too short. |
|- | |- | ||
− | | "How to Sell the Ponti Bridge" || A con artist tells the story of how he scammed a bunch of | + | | "How to Sell the Ponti Bridge" || A con artist tells the story of how he scammed a bunch of aristocrats into buying a bridge. |
|- | |- | ||
| "October in the Chair" || See my description in ''[[Fragile Things]]''. | | "October in the Chair" || See my description in ''[[Fragile Things]]''. | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | | "Chivalry" || An old woman finds the Holy Grail at a secondhand shop in the UK and buys it for her mantle | + | | "Chivalry" || An old woman finds the Holy Grail at a secondhand shop in the UK and buys it for her mantle, but Lancelot of Arthurian times comes seeking it. |
|- | |- | ||
| "The Price" || A story about the stray cats that show up at the author's house, and how one in particular protects his family from evil. It was okay. | | "The Price" || A story about the stray cats that show up at the author's house, and how one in particular protects his family from evil. It was okay. | ||
Line 44: | Line 44: | ||
| "Sunbird" || See my description in ''[[Fragile Things]]''. | | "Sunbird" || See my description in ''[[Fragile Things]]''. | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | | "The Witch's Headstone" || Preview | + | | "The Witch's Headstone" || Preview segment from ''[[The Graveyard Book]]''. |
|- | |- | ||
| "Instructions" || See my description in ''[[Fragile Things]]''. | | "Instructions" || See my description in ''[[Fragile Things]]''. | ||
Line 55: | Line 55: | ||
===Good=== | ===Good=== | ||
− | * | + | * All of the included stories were good, some were great. |
===Bad=== | ===Bad=== | ||
Line 61: | Line 61: | ||
===Ugly=== | ===Ugly=== | ||
− | * | + | * Nine of the eleven stories in this book were already printed in a previous anthologies, four were printed less than a year earlier in ''[[Fragile Things]]'', and one was just a preview of an upcoming book, much of which won't make sense to the reader because it's pulled from the middle of the book. This would be like buying a band's latest "Greatest Hits" album and discovering that nearly all of songs were published on the previous Greatest Hits albums you already own. It was really quite disappointing. |
==Media== | ==Media== |
Revision as of 09:46, 17 April 2024
M Is for Magic | ||||||||||||
Hardcover - USA - 1st edition. |
||||||||||||
|
M Is for Magic is compilation of short stories written by Neil Gaiman, published on 2007-06-06. Despite the book's theme implying it's for children, most of the subject matter is more appropriate for teens and adults. The Spanish title is much more accurate which translates to, "the cemetery without tombstones and other black stories." Nearly all of the stories in the book were previously published in Gaimen's other anthologies.
Contents
Personal
Own? | No. |
---|---|
Read? | Audiobook read by Neil Gaiman. |
Finished | 2024-04-16. |
Stories
Title | Notes |
---|---|
"The Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds" | A hard boiled crime story set in the world of fairy tales. The juxtaposition of the two genres made me laugh out loud multiple times. |
"Troll Bridge" | A tale about a little boy who meets a hungry bridge troll that will spare his life if he promises to return to be eaten when he's older. |
"Don't Ask Jack" | A cursed jack-in-the-box drives a family mad. Mildly creepy, but too short. |
"How to Sell the Ponti Bridge" | A con artist tells the story of how he scammed a bunch of aristocrats into buying a bridge. |
"October in the Chair" | See my description in Fragile Things. |
"Chivalry" | An old woman finds the Holy Grail at a secondhand shop in the UK and buys it for her mantle, but Lancelot of Arthurian times comes seeking it. |
"The Price" | A story about the stray cats that show up at the author's house, and how one in particular protects his family from evil. It was okay. |
"How to Talk to Girls at Parties" | See my description in Fragile Things. |
"Sunbird" | See my description in Fragile Things. |
"The Witch's Headstone" | Preview segment from The Graveyard Book. |
"Instructions" | See my description in Fragile Things. |
Review
Overall: |
— This section contains spoilers! —
Good
- All of the included stories were good, some were great.
Bad
- Nothing.
Ugly
- Nine of the eleven stories in this book were already printed in a previous anthologies, four were printed less than a year earlier in Fragile Things, and one was just a preview of an upcoming book, much of which won't make sense to the reader because it's pulled from the middle of the book. This would be like buying a band's latest "Greatest Hits" album and discovering that nearly all of songs were published on the previous Greatest Hits albums you already own. It was really quite disappointing.
Media
Representation
Strong female character? | Pass | Liza Hempstock is a fairly strong character. |
---|---|---|
Bechdel test? | Pass | There are some women who to each other briefly "October in the Chair." |
Strong person of color character? | Fail | There are black teens briefly mentioned in "How to Talk to Girls at Parties." |
Queer character? | Fail | There are no queer characters. |
Quotes
Titles
Language | Native | Transliteration | Translation |
---|---|---|---|
English | M Is for Magic | ||
Spanish | El cementerio sin lápidas y otras historias negras | El cementerio sin lapidas y otras historias negras | The cemetery without tombstones and other black stories |
Links
Categories:
- Books
- Books Published in 2007
- Adult Books
- Books written by Neil Gaiman
- Fiction
- Anthology
- Book Genre - Fantasy
- Media Theme - Adventure
- Media Theme - Fantasy
- Media Theme - Horror
- Media Theme - Urban Fantasy
- Books I Don't Own
- Books I've Read
- Books Rated - 4
- Books with a strong female character
- Books that pass the Bechdel test
- Books without a strong person of color character
- Books without a queer character