Difference between revisions of "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone"

From TheAlmightyGuru
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 1: Line 1:
'''''Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone''''' is a book written by JK Rowling, and the first in the Harry Potter series. I read the book after it was gifted to me by a girl who wss really into the series.
+
'''''Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone''''' is a book written by JK Rowling, and the first in the Harry Potter series. I read the book after it was gifted to me by a girl who was really into the series.
  
 
==Reviews==
 
==Reviews==
 
===Good===
 
===Good===
* The book has wonderful characters. The hero and friends are lovable, the various professors are fun, and the villains are wretched.
+
* The book has wonderful characters. Harry, Ron, and Hermione are all lovable, Dumbledore, McGonagall, and the other professors are fun, Snape and the Dursleys are nicely wretched.
* Hogwarts is wonderfully described. Everything seems fresh and magical, unlike in the later books where it seems more formulaic.
+
* Hogwarts is wonderfully described. Everything seems fresh and magical, sentient pictures, moving staircases, secret passageways, dangerous monsters, etc. Unlike in the later books where it seems more formulaic.
* I like how Snape is believed to be very evil, but through a certain lens, he's actually a hero (but still rather nasty).
+
* I like how Snape is believed to be very evil, but through a certain lens, he's actually a hero. Of course, he's still a bully, but you can appreciate him.
  
 
===Bad===
 
===Bad===
Line 11: Line 11:
 
* I don't like how so many people have alliterative names, I suppose it could just be a quirk of the wizarding world, but it seems rather false.
 
* I don't like how so many people have alliterative names, I suppose it could just be a quirk of the wizarding world, but it seems rather false.
 
* Trolls are supposed to be deadly, but the three bumble their way through its attack without so much as a scratch.
 
* Trolls are supposed to be deadly, but the three bumble their way through its attack without so much as a scratch.
* Quidditch could be a lot of fun, but it has two ruining features. The snitch is worth 150 points, and the match doesn't end until the snitch is caught. This pretty much makes scoring with the quaffle pointless, as the snitch usually pushes the catcher into the lead. It also ends the game either far too soon or too late making play impracticable.
+
* Quidditch could be a lot of fun, but it has several ruining features. Since the snitch is worth 150 points, catching it usually guarantees a victory for the catcher, making scoring with the quaffle pretty much pointless. Also, since the match ends the moment the snitch is caught, but not until, most games should end very quickly or take forever, neither outcome is impracticable. Finally, since brooms vary so much in quality, it becomes possible to essentially buy your way to victory.
  
 
===Ugly===
 
===Ugly===

Revision as of 09:24, 23 August 2016

Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone is a book written by JK Rowling, and the first in the Harry Potter series. I read the book after it was gifted to me by a girl who was really into the series.

Reviews

Good

  • The book has wonderful characters. Harry, Ron, and Hermione are all lovable, Dumbledore, McGonagall, and the other professors are fun, Snape and the Dursleys are nicely wretched.
  • Hogwarts is wonderfully described. Everything seems fresh and magical, sentient pictures, moving staircases, secret passageways, dangerous monsters, etc. Unlike in the later books where it seems more formulaic.
  • I like how Snape is believed to be very evil, but through a certain lens, he's actually a hero. Of course, he's still a bully, but you can appreciate him.

Bad

  • Harry's natural affinity of flying is unbelievable for a kid locked in a cupboard his whole life.
  • I don't like how so many people have alliterative names, I suppose it could just be a quirk of the wizarding world, but it seems rather false.
  • Trolls are supposed to be deadly, but the three bumble their way through its attack without so much as a scratch.
  • Quidditch could be a lot of fun, but it has several ruining features. Since the snitch is worth 150 points, catching it usually guarantees a victory for the catcher, making scoring with the quaffle pretty much pointless. Also, since the match ends the moment the snitch is caught, but not until, most games should end very quickly or take forever, neither outcome is impracticable. Finally, since brooms vary so much in quality, it becomes possible to essentially buy your way to victory.

Ugly

  • Nothing.